Milburn opens the door to work, but better frontline jobs will help young people stay and get on
by Clare McNeil, Chief Executive, Timewise

Alan Milburn’s ambitious review finally puts work at the heart of the welfare state. It has the potential to change the lives of hundreds of thousands of young people. Its call for serious investment in employment support, and a legal opportunity guarantee for all 18 to 24 year olds for the first time, could open doors to work, while wider reforms to health and education will help young people get there.
But the proposed reforms cannot fully succeed unless frontline work, where most young people start out, changes too. More than half of young workers aged 30 and under are in frontline sectors providing the vital services we rely on every day, working as shop assistants, waiting and kitchen staff, care workers, warehouse operatives and construction labourers. Our new research, to be published next month, shows these sectors lose workers to ill health at more than double the rate of other jobs.
Too often, and often because of the pressures employers face, frontline work is poorly designed for workers: inflexible shift patterns with changes and cancellations at short notice, insecure zero-hours contracts, intensive monitoring, and little control over how they work. For a young person entering the job market today, a frontline job too often means insecurity and instability, and it’s easy to see why people working in these conditions are more likely to see their health suffer.
Where we disagree with Alan Milburn is over any suggestion that the new responsibilities in the Employment Rights Act will stop employers hiring. Our work with frontline employers shows that improving “shift-life balance”, by designing shifts that meet both staff and operational needs, delivers measurable improvements in absence, recruitment and retention.
Many employers show that seasonal and fluctuating demand can be managed while still giving young workers fair notice and predictable hours. If the government commits, as the report proposes, to doubling the employer National Insurance threshold for 21 to 24 year olds in retail and hospitality, it should not back away from the Employment Rights Act reforms that give those same young people more secure and predictable hours.
The vast majority of young people are ambitious for the future and willing to work hard. They also want security and some control over when and how they work. That shouldn’t be too much to ask. And for young people with disabilities or health conditions (45 per cent of young people who are not in education, employment or training live with a disability), it is essential.
Employment support will only deliver lasting value if the jobs people move into are ones they can stay in. More than half of people who move into work from economic inactivity each year find frontline jobs, but over half of these jobs last less than four months. There is a real risk that significant investment in back-to-work support is lost, as young people move into work only to fall straight back out again.
The review is right that for too long, government has focused on making young people more employable, while assuming the market would create the jobs. The same mistake must not be made now: the market alone will not create enough good jobs, of the right kind, to deliver real opportunity for young people. The problems with frontline work won’t be fixed by mandate from the top, and there is no one-size-fits-all solution. We need a sector-by-sector approach, led by employers and unions working in partnership with government, to change the way frontline work is organised. There is a real win-win here: workers get secure, stable and fair work, and employers get a motivated, healthy workforce.
Employers should take the lead, and government should back them, to match the ambition of Alan Milburn’s reforms with equally ambitious changes to the way frontline work is designed.
Published November 2026